I know this is sort of old news, but the more I think about it the more and more upset I get!
Babies getting kidney stones and infections! That makes me want to cry. Right after Asher was born I had a kidney infection and kidney stone that put me in the hospital twice. It hurt SO bad (in my opinion MUCH worse than labor) and I can't even begin to imagine a baby having to go through it.

Tian Yaowen, who is 15 months old and has kidney stones, cries in a ward of the Tongji Hospital in Wuhan. From CNN.com
All because they drank formula that had been PURPOSELY tainted with Melanine, a chemical they use to make plastic. The formula company was trying to cut corners and make it look like the formula had more protein in it that it really did. They KNEW that BABIES would be drinking their product and they DIDN'T CARE! Oh man, it make me SO angry I could kick something! (pause... envision Heather kicking the leg of the desk)
I realize that formula isn't all bad. When I was in the hospital for my kidney infection, and on nasty antibiotics, Asher had to have formula for a little while. I have to admit that I was grateful for it. So, I'm not totally against formula. I believe that how a woman chooses to feed her baby is personal decision and should be respected. But with that said, I think that the tactics that formula companies use to get women to bottle feed instead of breastfeed are down right unethical.
For example, in some 3rd world countries formula companies (cough... Nestle--makers of Good Start and Gerber) provide women with samples of formula while they are in the hospital. Telling them that is a better way to feed their baby. This interferes with a woman's breastfeeding, decreasing her milk supply and making her baby dependent upon the infant formula. For most 3rd world women formula is much too expensive and so they water it down. Often the water they have access to is unclean, and so not only are the babies malnourished but also get diarrhea. UNICEF (The United Nations Children's Fund) predicts that one and half million lives could be saved each year by reversing the decline in breastfeeding.
Now for the classic shock effect picture.
If you haven't seen this picture before it is of a mother at the Children's Hospital in Islamabad, Pakistan, taken by UNICEF. The babies are twins, a boy on the left and a girl on the right. The mother was told she wouldn't have enough milk to feed both and chose to breastfeed the boy and bottle feed the girl. The girl died not long after this picture was taken. UNICEF says that the mother said "Use my picture if it will help."
Formula companies make me SO angry! The WHO (World Health Organization), in order to protect mothers and babies, has passed a code that formula makers are suppose to follow when marketing their products. Here are the guidelines. See how many of them don't seem to apply in the US (am I the only one who got 2 free cases of formula in the mail-- that I didn't ask for?).
Code for the Marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes
- No advertising of any of these products to the public.
- No free samples to mothers.
- No promotion of products in health care facilities, including the distribution of free or low-cost supplies.
- No company sales representatives to advise mothers.
- No gifts or personal samples to health workers.
- No words or pictures idealizing artificial feeding, or pictures of infants on labels of infant milk containers.
- Information to health workers should be scientific and factual.
- All information on artificial infant feeding, including that on labels, should explain the benefits of breastfeeding, and the costs and hazards associated with artificial feeding.
- Unsuitable products, such as sweetened condensed milk, should not be promoted for babies.
- Manufacturers and distributors should comply with the Code's provisions even if countries have not adopted laws or other measures.









7 comments:
wow, that is way sad. i am a great supporter of breastfeeding, too. i can't believe that photo. the poor girl!!!!
Heather, I love your blog. I wish we knew each other in real life. I think we would get along great.
Because my son's birth didn't go the way I wanted it to, I was more determined than ever to make breast feeding work. I actually would like to become a lactation consultant. I can't agree more with what you said and could give a week long class about this topic! Though I think everyone would be bored but me.
Amen, sista! This is a subject I can get passionate about! In college I took a business ethics class and we did a case study on this exact thing! They actually used to do the same thing in the US! They were called milk nurses and they dressed just like a regular nurse, came into the hospitals and the new moms had no idea they weren't even affiliated with the hospital. They would give them samples and tell them that formula was better for their babies. They would give enough so that the baby learned to prefer formula and the mother's milk supply diminished sufficiently or dried up altogether. That way there wasn't much of a choice and they would have to buy the formula. It really wasn't that long ago (70s) that the government--or more accurately groups such as the American Academy of Pediatrictions-- stepped in to get rid of this practice and started heavily promoting the benefits of breastfeeding and encouraging mothers to nurse. The government is supposed to "monitor" the formula companies' practices (haha)--yet the US does get away with breaking most the rules. So of course, you still get samples in the mail and even in the hospital! And while it seems nice to get free stuff, most people have no idea where the practice started and the agenda of these companies! It really is disgusting that they could care less about these little precious human lives and all in the name of making money! It is even more disgusting when they do it in 3rd world countries where, just as you said, they can't afford it but have little choice and therefore have to water it down with contaminated water. So sad!
Here are a few sites with more info you might be interested in:
http://www.babymilkaction.org/
http://boycottnestle.blogspot.com/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nestl%C3%A9_boycott
I know this address is pretty long but you can read the actual case study right out of my ethics book! http://books.google.com/books?id=mS38Lo5VVjMC&pg=PA435&lpg=PA435&dq=milk+nurse,+nestle&source=web&ots=0tjbEYzEF2&sig=28OXgPOPsctdShzXA2ZffHwxUnY&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=9&ct=result#PPA435,M1
PS-I know this was quite a rant but I can't help but get worked up over it, especially when I think of my precious new baby ever being in such circumstances. Honestly, how can these people live with themselves!
Amen and Amen! You know I'm with you on this.
Joseph and I are in Canada because Joseph is getting his masters from the University of Toronto.
We'll be in Provo from the 17-20 this month and will be in town from christmas to new years in December, maybe we could get together sometime :)
I hope all is well with your family. Tell Jon hi.
I am totally with you on this whole thing. When I was in the hospital with Mimi the nurses were shocked that I wanted them to bring her to me during the night when she got hungry. They kept trying to talk me into letting them supplement her so I could sleep. Sleep was not as important to me as building up my milk supply was. I am just grateful that my kids picked it up easily. I'm with you that it is a very personal decision for every mother, and this was my decision. I miss nursing Mimi now, and I'm grateful that I was able to give her that gift for so long.
This is why I boycott Nestle- I can't support a business that ignores the WHO's code. (Remember that when you buy Halloween candy!) :)
Post a Comment